Taxonomic Swap 74411 (Guardado el 04/04/2020)

Fixing small typo in species name.

desconocido
Añadido por manila_folder el abril 4, 2020 08:55 TARDE | Comprometido por manila_folder el 04 de abril de 2020
Reemplazado con

Comentarios

@manila_folder I'm not sure this is set up properly. Are you trying to say that

POWO has http://www.plantsoftheworldonline.org/?q=Saussurea+gossipiphora as an active taoxn and
http://www.plantsoftheworldonline.org/?q=Saussurea+gossypiphora as a synonym of Saussurea laniceps

Are you proposing to deviate from POWO? If so what are you proposing? It doesn't look like the way you edited the taxon framework relationships captures that deviation

Thanks

Publicado por loarie hace alrededor de 4 años

@loarie The distinction I am indicating is between S. gossypiphora Wall, a synonym of S. laniceps Hand.-Mazz., and S. gossypiphora D.Don., which The Plant List recognizes.

Publicado por manila_folder hace alrededor de 4 años

got it - but the POWO (our reference) has Saussurea gossipiphora D.Don and Saussurea laniceps Hand.-Mazz. as the active taxa. The way you've curated it here Saussurea gossipiphora D.Don is no longer active and instead Saussurea laniceps Hand.-Mazz. and S. gossypiphora are active. Since this does not follow POWO, are you intending to deviate from POWO or is there an error in how you curated? If the former can you flag Saussurea gossipiphora explain why a deviation is necessary, ie why do you think POWO's use of S. gossipiphora is wrong and we should instead use S. gossypiphora?

Since we try to minimize deviations from POWO, these proposals (flags) should ideally be made about a week in advance of curating in the direction of the deviation so other curators have a chance to discuss. I'm generally in favor of first reaching out to POWO directly and seeing if they'll make the change there which saves us having to make and maintain these deviations which is a lot of work

Publicado por loarie hace alrededor de 4 años

@loarie thanks for following up. I think the fault is on my end regarding a single typo in the species name (S. gossipiphora vs. S. gossypiphora). Please ignore my changes - I agree with your logic and with what POWO indicates.

Publicado por manila_folder hace alrededor de 4 años

Ok I'll create a new swap with Saussurea gossypiphora 1064955as the input and Saussurea gossipiphora 795555 as the output https://www.inaturalist.org/taxon_changes/74616

Publicado por loarie hace alrededor de 4 años

Agregar un comentario

Acceder o Crear una cuenta para agregar comentarios.